Is Education a Lost Cause?

Anyone who knows me knows that I am passionate about learning and could wax lyrical about how important education is and how we have to try our best to ‘get it right’. As I started to prepare to write this article; a task that asked me to list successes within education, I was shocked about what I learnt about myself … I lean towards pessimism!


Why is this? I launched into research and soon soothed myself by the fact that the human condition favours pessimism over optimism as it sounds more plausible. For example: tell someone that everything will work out fine and you will probably get a polite dismissal or platitude. Tell someone that they are in danger (or something serious is going wrong) and you will have their undivided attention!


I brought this insight with me to a recent lunchtime chat with a placement student of mine (who has recently left school) and her mentor. To their credit and good humour, they allowed me to ramble on until I asked them about their views on what has been a success within their own educational experience.


Silence.


I took this as first hand proof of the human proclivity towards pessimism.


But when they answered in joint chorus, “knowing that my teacher cared for me”, I could not help but smile.


Pastoral care is a true and lasting success of education. Our children and young people come to our schools from a range of backgrounds and experiences but school is the constant; a place filled with people who are there just for them. Educational debate around the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is huge at the moment. I would champion its use in regards to personalising the learning experience or streamlining processes but it can never replace that which is most important - relationships. We all need and crave a deep sense of connection and belonging no matter what our age and stage.


With lunch over I wanted to find out more about the successes there have been within education over the years and with no one else to consult, I turned to my computer; a Large Language Model (LLM) to be precise. Immediately, as soon as I hit ‘enter’, a profound list of accomplishments appeared on screen:


  • More students than ever are in school
  • Technology is revolutionising education
  • Teaching has become more inclusive and innovative
  • We are learning to value teachers more (Are we? Sorry my pessimism needs to challenge this one!)
  • Education is adapting to global changes


My screen was positively overflowing with optimism. ‘Definitely not human’ I thought to myself. But the AI’s summary heading made me pause: ‘Embrace Creativity for the Next Frontier”.


This made me think. Creativity, alongside relationships, is another success of educational practice. We are all creative, either consciously or subconsciously, in whatever task we are doing and it is our role as educators to help our pupils be creative in design, thought or approach, especially in a world that is embracing technology more and more.


As I write, two alternate thoughts swirl within my mind:

Does educational progress happen too slowly to notice? Or do topical, educational trends occur too quick to ignore?


The latter would always make education a failure by default. All I know is that continued improvements within the education sector must be built upon evidence based research, utilising the learnings from cognitive science. For me, continued success within pedagogy must be formed upon knowing what works.


For the sake of having a balanced argument, I will end on an optimistic note:

“Rather than lamenting what’s not working, we should focus on what’s been built and how we can expand upon success. Education is not a lost cause—it’s a dynamic force that’s been evolving for the better over the past 15 years. Let’s continue to push it forward, not by fearing failure, but by embracing it as part of the process toward even greater achievements.” LLM 2024


Not too shabby, AI, not too shabby at all.


BIOGRAPHY

Bernard Noble is an educational consultant and founder of Learning Me. With a background as a school leader, pastoral care lead and SENDCO, he has expertise in pedagogy, educational policy, nurture, neurodiversity and learning disabilities. Passionate about holistic education, Bernard is a strong advocate for making emotional health and wellbeing strategies explicit.

Bernard Noble • February 24, 2025

What happens when creativity, young people, education and community come together?

By Ann Beatty • August 25, 2026
Seeds of Hope are everywhere! “I wasn't quite sure what to expect when I arrived at Stage at the Lake…” But it was special to meet all of the Calderdale team in person, who had brought this four-day event together so successfully. Sometimes an event stays with you long after the final performance has finished. My visit to Stage at the Lake at the beautiful Shibden Hall in Calderdale was one of those occasions. As UNESCO ASPnet UK Coordinator, I was delighted to be invited as a guest, but what I experienced was much more than simply attending an event. Here, in the grounds of a house steeped in history, the past, present and future seemed to meet. The English Chamber Orchestra filled the setting with music, Northern Ballet brought movement and storytelling to life, and throughout there was a wonderful sense of creativity, community and possibility. And then there were the parklets; a unique gardening festival at Shibden Park celebrating community, creativity and the power of nature to bring people together. At its heart was a specially commissioned trail of ten micro show gardens, designed and built by community groups from across Calderdale. It was wonderful to see spaces where ideas, conversations and creativity were flourishing and connecting through Seeds of Hope. I cannot wait to see them transported to their ‘forever homes’. Standing there, I found myself thinking about what we mean when we talk about education, culture and hope. 

Alfa Liv Kalkil - Math concepts for popular literacy classes in Haiti

By Chancy Jak • August 25, 2026
2025 During the annual fomasyon for Alfa monitors, Antoliyis Pye gave an extensive presentation on how best to introduce and develop basic math concepts in literacy classes. The response to his insight and enthusiasm led to our decision to create our own math book for Alfa participants.  In Haiti and around the world, illiterate market women and peasant farmers develop their own techniques for calculating and recording numbers. However, in providing literacy for the development of our people, we must also introduce the world of conventional numeracy. These skills lead to logical thinking, problem-solving, and the ability to interpret and make informed decisions on numerical evidence. For a year we worked together to draft the contents of our Alfa Liv Kalkil, seek illustrations, create layout, and finally take our product to the local printer. Funds were provided for 350 copies, enough for each Alfa participant at each of our sites at the present level of attendance. 2026 Our next step was to fully engage each Alfa monitor in the process for introduction and use of Liv Kalkil in Alfa classes. Our two day fomasyon for 2026 was dedicated to ensuring that each member of our team was familiar with the book and comfortable in implementing the concepts with Alfa participants. The sessions were a great success. Every monitor was extremely pleased with this new tool which will allow them and their classes to work together in the world of mathematics. Liv Kalkil is now in service for every participant throughout Alfa, from Limonade itself out to sites in the hills and along the river. It is with some excitement that the monitors and participants are beginning to use our very own, home-grown, math book. In the same way that we already had Goute Sel*, Lekti Netale*, Ti Koze Sou Istwa Peyi Dayiti*, we are proud to have this math book which advances our shared work for the development of our people. We are profoundly grateful to all those who have encouraged and supported us in developing this book. We want to thank our dedicated team of monitors, the Alfa support team in Columbus, Ann Beatty and the Steve Sinnott Foundation, and the many others who contribute to our literacy programme. Chancy Jak (Alfa Co-ordinator) Antoliyis Pye (senior monitor) *Goute Sel: Taste of Salt (base text for Alfa literacy classes) *Lekti Netale (reading comprehension) *Ti Koze Sou Istwa Peyi Dayiti (stories from Haitian history; Alfa second level)

Five Days, 64 Educators, One Renewed Mission

By Marie Antoinette Corr • August 10, 2026
Every teacher has a time in their career when a student needs someone to listen to them instead of just a lesson plan. Schools have been preparing for that moment for far too long. That started to alter on Friday, August 7, 2026. After completing a five-day guidance and counselling program in the RED 2 West hall in Brikama, 64 educators left with certificates and something more substantial than paper. They left with a duty: to be a support system for young people negotiating the challenging realities of school and life, a listening ear for a struggling student, and a source of advice for a colleague. Why This Training Matters During the closing ceremony, union leaders and education administrators made it clear that schools need counsellors, and they need them right now. The message is grounded in reality. Today's students face an ever-more complicated array of social, emotional, financial, and personal obstacles as they enter the school each morning. Teachers are the first to notice it. They are the ones in the classroom when a youngster needs someone to notice, when a student becomes quiet, or when grades decline for no apparent reason. Guidance and counselling have traditionally been viewed as optional extras rather than essential components of a school's operations. This instruction directly challenged that notion. Counselling and guidance are not extras. It contributes to the success of a school. Five Days of Learning and Practice Over the course of the week, participants moved beyond theory into practice, building the listening skills, guidance techniques, and support strategies they'll need to respond to real situations in real time. It wasn't just about acquiring knowledge; it was about rehearsing the kind of presence that makes a difference when a student or colleague needs it most. By the final day, the room held a shared sense of purpose. Participants reflected on what the five days had given them, not only new skills, but a renewed sense of why they came into education in the first place. They thanked the funders who made the training possible and made a collective commitment: to serve with diligence, empathy, and purpose. Taking It Beyond the Training Room The real test of this training won't happen in Brikama; it'll happen in the weeks and months ahead, in classrooms, corridors, staffrooms, and communities across the region. The 64 newly certified counsellors were challenged to carry what they learned into every one of those spaces: to notice the learner who's struggling silently, to check in on the colleague who seems overwhelmed, to be the steady presence that a school community can lean on. That's the real outcome of a training like this. Not just a certificate, but a shift in what's considered normal: a school culture where guidance and counselling sit at the centre of education, not the margins.